The Penny Loafer

$185
$185
974 reviews
The Penny Loafer in Portobello shown from the top.
The Penny Loafer in Portobello shown from the top.
hover | Model wearing The Penny Loafer in Portobello.
side | The Penny Loafer in Portobello shown from the side.
Close up of the heel of The Penny Loafer in Portobello, with Rothy's signature blue halo.
Close up of the toe and vamp of The Penny Loafer in Portobello.
Color
Black
Cortado
Portobello
ReVelvetโ„ข Dove
ReVelvetโ„ข Lilac
ReVelvetโ„ข Syrah
Blue Raffia-Knit
Classic Cat
Conch Raffia-Knit
Light Pink
Tux
Cinnamon Raffia-Knit
ReVelvetโ„ข Bistro
ReVelvetโ„ข Black
ReVelvetโ„ข Navy
ReVelvetโ„ข Ruby
ReVelvetโ„ข Russet
ReVelvetโ„ข Woodland
Size
5
5.5
6
6.5
7
7.5
8
8.5
9
9.5
10
10.5
11
11.5
12
12.5
13
Fits true to size.
Add to cart
Find in-store

Free shipping on all orders.
30 days to return or exchange. Learn more.
The Penny Loafer in Portobello shown from the top.

The Penny Loafer

(974)
Size Chart

Sharp, sustainable and comfy AF. With a classic loafer style and a contoured insole, The Penny Loafer fits true to size. Learn More

Find Your Size

  1. Trace your foot on paper.

  2. Measure from heel to the longest toe.

  3. Use measurement to find your size.

Size Chart
Still not sure what your size is?
Let's Chat
An icon depicting a shoe in a vessel of water.
MACHINE WASHABLE

Toss in the wash with cold water. Air dry. Boom.

An icon depicting a feather drifting above a pile of pillows.
PILLOW-LIKE COMFORT

Features a soft, plush footbed for easy-to-wear comfort.

An icon depicting a plastic bottle.
RECYCLED PLASTIC BOTTLES

It took about 16 plastic bottles to knit these shoes. See how we calculate it.

Video of a model walking wearing The Penny Loafer.

Details

The Penny Loafer in Portobello


  • Soft, premium upper in a cool earthy brown.ย 
  • Classic loafer style with a rounded toe and penny-slot detail.
  • Cushy, contoured insoles in beige give you endless support. Wear them all day.
  • Heel padding offers extra comfort and grip. No sliding around.ย 
  • Sturdy brown rubber outsole with non-slip traction.

SKU 359_003_PTB
Reviews
974 reviews

Washing Instructions

  • All of our styles are machine washableโ€”so they last for the long haul. Learn more.
  • Slip out insoles. Toss insoles and shoes in the wash with cold water.ย 
  • Air dry. No heat, please.
  • Wear again and again.

Sustainability

  • Knit from Rothyโ€™s signature thread, which is spun from plastic bottles. Learn more.
  • It took about 16 plastic bottles to knit this pair of shoes.
Close up shot of The Penny Loafer in Black. Classic loafer look with sleek lines and sustainable craftsmanship. Model wearing The Penny Loafer in Black. Close up shot of The Penny Loafer in Black. Classic loafer look with sleek lines and sustainable craftsmanship.
THE PENNY LOAFER
  • Comfy AF. Contoured footbed, sturdy outsole and a padded back heel for all-around comfort.
  • Tailored AND trendy. Classic loafer look with sleek lines and sustainable craftsmanship.
  • Look out, leather. Knit with recycled plastic bottles for a sustainable and washable style.

Overall rating: 4.61191 / 5 from 974 reviews.

AI Generated Review Summary

The Penny Loafer in Portobello Soft features a premium upper with a cool earthy brown color. The fit is consistently described as perfect or great, and the comfort is praised for its cushy, contoured insoles and heel padding. However, some customers find the shoes uncomfortably tight, and sizing can be inconsistent.

Summary topics

  • Break-in Period (3%): Customers keep praising the product for its comfort and its ability to require no break-in period.
  • Aesthetic Appeal (16%): Many customers brought up that the shoes have a great look and are comfortable, making them a popular choice.
  • Color Appeal (12%): Customers loved the color, with many expressing their admiration for it multiple times in the reviews.
  • Fit Accuracy (13%): It was observed by customers that the fit of the product is consistently described as perfect or great.
  • Sizing Consistency (7%): The feedback is varied, some reviewers found the sizing to be inconsistent, while others found it true to size.

Review topics: ["size","fit","feel","issues","color","look","quality","pants","fabric","material","style","pair","weight","comfort","design","shoes","texture","weather","shape","loafers","snug","padding","lining","loafer","pattern","width","rothy","feet","break","socks"].

Review highlights

  • "The cute style, comfort and color makes a perfect addition to my growing collection of Rothy's!" — Mary C.
  • "But these shoes were a perfect size with absolutely no pain points and a fantastic classic look." — Betsy W.
  • "Lovely color, perfect fit, amazing feel." — Ash H.

Reviews

Love love.

"I have a few pair of Rothy’s and the sizes are usually all over the place. I am a true 9 with a medium foot. I bought these in a 10, especially knowing they do not stretch. I don’t wear socks but there is enough room that I could. If it helps, I wear a 10 in the Daily Loafer and a 9.5 in The Daily Driver."

— Lauren F. (5/5)

Perfect loader!

"I never thought it would be able to wear a Rothy as I have a size 11 foot. But these shoes were a perfect size with absolutely no pain points and a fantastic classic look. I am so excited to become an official Rothy wearer!"

— Betsy W. (5/5)

In style

"I purchased these loafers on a whim when shopping with my daughter at the the Newbury St store. (Very helpful sales consultants. ) Did I need another pair of Rothy's? (We all know the answer to that!) But loafers are having a moment again and these were a bit more stylish than just a plain brown. I'm between a 7.5 and an 8 in Rothy's and the 8.5 fit me best. (I tried on a few pairs). I wear them without socks and have walked a distance with no issues."

— Peggy R. (5/5)

Runs smaller than the daily drivers

"I have the Daily Drivers in a 7.5 which fit perfectly, so I ordered the loafers in the same size. They are definitely tighter. (FYI I have very narrow feet which is why I find this surprising. ) The toe area looks and feels narrower than the Daily Drivers which is why my feet feel more squished. I'd love to try an 8, but am overseas, so will just wear with very thin socks. Given the material, I'm sure they'll eventually stretch with some wear."

— GENIE P. (5/5)

Nice shoe but ran small

"I tried on the size shoe ordered for size but the style was not in the store. Maybe the sizing isn’t consistent. Ir felt a little smaller. Unfortunately, the shoe was delayed and I thought although it was a little smaller it would work. I got blisters on my heels and could not wear the shoes for the rest of my trip."

— Elaine B. (3/5)

Love the style but hate how it fits

"The sides and the back of the shoes are not tall (high) enough. They look nice but I feel like they don’t fit nicely. Also I was expecting it to be more comfortable but they are just okay."

— Koeun L. (2/5)

Love the shoes but…..

"Love the shoes but it would be so wonderful if you made a wide shoe selection. I had to go up 1/2 size for my wide feet — bunion and hammer toes. I have two other pair of Rothy’s!"

— Marge J. (5/5)

Cinnamon never looked so sweet!

"These bring a new meaning to loafing around. Love love love these! They are so comfortable. No break in period at all and they look great with jeans!!!"

— Jennifer C. (5/5)

Not the most comfortable Rothy

"This is my 8th pair of Rothy shoes and first time I’ve had an issue with the fit.., the toe box is narrow and tight. The size up was too large and my foot kept slipping out when I walked. Maybe it is the style, not as comfortable as all other Rothys I own."

— Reiko T. (3/5)

Love!!!

"The red is a beautiful color and they are wide enough for my difficult feet. I usually have a problem with the stitching on the top of loafers cutting into my foot but not with these!"

— Amy C. (5/5)

Q&A
WOMEN'S SHOES
The Kids Mary Jane in ReVelvet Metallic Twinkleberry.
KIDS SHOES
Collection shot of the studded bucket bags.
BAGS & ACCESSORIES
The Men's Driver in Dark Green and Syrah.
MEN'S SHOES