Review topics: ["size","fit","strap","support","color","look","quality","issues","fabric","comfort","style","shoes","feel","padding","band","jeans","comfy","mary janes","feet","cruise","toe","cushion","pair","rothy","insole","break","soles","dress","walk","wear"].
Reviews
Love the color and style!
"I have several pairs of Rothy's shoes & have found that their sizing differs with almost each pair. This pair is running larger than my others & almost slips off. Because of their sizing, I have always ordered a 1/2 size larger than I wear & that usually works with their shoes."
— Lois W. (3/5)
simply adorable
"I am very new to Mary Jane’s but these looked really cute so I wanted to give them a try. They are right now my most favorite shoe. They’re super cute. Very comfortable. I love the elastic strap on top. It just feels very comfortable. I am now purchasing these in black because I like them so much."
— Ashley I. (5/5)
Cutest Shoe for Spring & Summer
"I'm obsessed with these. I wanted a flat that was comfy and would go with most of my spring and summer clothes, and these are just perfect! I love the color and the sparkly gold trim really elevates the shoe. I've gotten so many compliments so far! I will say the toe box feels constricting if I walk a ton in them due to my feet swelling, but they are the perfect fit otherwise. If that's an issue for you with any shoe, then I would go up a half size!"
— Samantha B. (5/5)
Cute but missed the mark
"The Cruisers are very cute, and I love the wider fit. The exchange process was also easy when the size 9 ended up being too large. Unfortunately, the 8. 5 still didn't work for me because the elastic strap has too much stretch and feels loose. I wore them to work, and as the day went on, my foot kept slipping out more and more because the strap didn't feel supportive enough. Since I wore them outside, I can’t return them now. Sizing down also wouldn't work. I think the design really needs a sturdier or adjustable strap to better account for the amount of stretch in the elastic."
— Margaret C. (3/5)
Cute but no support whatsoever
"Imagine walking barefoot but you've actually got these on your feet. If that's your thing, you'll love these mary janes. I found out right away that I cannot walk long distances or all day in these because the soles and insoles are very thin. They're cute and the color is lovely, so if my outing involves lots of sitting, these will be perfect."
— Alison L. (3/5)
Super light and comfy
"Finally! A pair of shoes that feel light on my feet. I do a lot of walking around New York City and by the end of the day my feet always usually ache- but no more!!! The light-weightedness and comfort from my Rothys is really making a difference. I'd buy them in all colors if I could!!!"
— Clare A. (5/5)
Cruiser Mary Jane
"Rothy's cruiser is very comfortable! They finally put some cushion in the shoe for support so that your feet can walk in them for miles! I have a lot of the older models and there is just any support for your feet although I still like them. I walked 6 miles in these around Boston on Mother's Day. Thank you Rothy's!"
— Brenda L. (5/5)
Finally found the best work shoes!
"I’ve tried so many other brands for work! Sketchers, Clark’s, Dr Sholl’s etc etc. . fitting my style and comfort, these are by far the best! I have wide feet and they stretch perfectly because of the awesome material. Pricey but worth it and they always have promos and sales!"
— Danielle F. (5/5)
Not as comfy as I hoped
"I love them, when I first put them on, they feel great, fit like a sock, cozy and stretchy. But after a few hours my big toes start to ache. I guess they are too small?, but they feel perfect when I first put them on, and I don’t think you want too much room in the front, it would look weird. I wish I had a half size larger, I think. ?"
— Patrice B. (3/5)
So far pretty good!
"I am a teacher and on my feet walking all day. I got no back heel blisters and no marks from the strap from wearing them on the first day, which is amazing! I did have some soreness on the ball of my foot while walking back to my car so I’m guessing the arch support is lacking a bit. Otherwise, I’ll just wear gym shoes to and from school and these during the day and I’ll be great! Can also wear them for a cute night out or brunch!"
— Hannah F. (4/5)