The Square Mary Jane

$100

Regular price
Sale price: $100

3645 reviews

The Square Mary Jane in Lollipop shown from the top.

Color

Black

Lollipop Red

Wren

Cream Captoe

Classic Cheetah

Size

5.5

6.5

7.5

8.5

9.5

10.5

11.5

12.5

Fits true to size.

Find in-store

Select a size to see availability near you.

Free shipping on all orders.
30 days to return or exchange. Learn more.

MACHINE WASHABLE

Toss in the wash with cold water. Air dry. Boom.

PILLOW-LIKE COMFORT

Features a soft, plush footbed for easy-to-wear comfort.

RECYCLED PLASTIC BOTTLES

It took about 9 plastic bottles to knit these shoes. See how we calculate it.

Details

The Square Mary Jane in Lollipop Red

Soft, flexible upper in red.
Features a slim, flexible strap that keeps your feet secure.
Comfortable insoles in beige and durable outsoles in tortoise shell.

SKU 075_015_LLPRD

Reviews

3645 reviews

Washing Instructions

All of our styles are machine washable—so they last for the long haul. Learn more.
Slip out insoles. Toss insoles and shoes in the wash with cold water.
Air dry. No heat, please.
Wear again and again.

Sustainability

Knit from Rothy’s signature thread, which is spun from plastic bottles. Learn more.
It took about 9 plastic bottles to knit this pair of shoes.

Close up of the toe and vamp of The Square Mary Jane, shown from the top.

THE SQUARE MARY JANE

Forever favorite. Timeless and trendy?! Oh yes, especially with a unique rounded-square toe.
Feels incredible. Super soft, lightweight knit construction adds extra comfort to every step. Ahh.
Easy to wear. Stretchy straps are extra comfy—and give your look a lil’ something extra.

Overall rating: 4.411684 / 5 from 3646 reviews.

AI Generated Review Summary

The Square Mary Jane in Lollipop Red offers a soft, flexible upper and a slim, adjustable strap for secure fit. Customers appreciate the comfortable insoles and durable outsoles. While opinions vary on the strap's comfort and the shoe's fit, the color and style are highly praised.

Summary topics

Fit (14%): It was noted by customers that the fit of the shoes is perfect and they fit perfectly. (Common opinion)
Mary Jane Design (7%): Customers appreciated the Mary Janes, with many expressing their love and admiration for the brand.
Size (11%): The feedback is varied, some customers found the size to be too small, while others found it true to size.
Comfort for Desk Work (5%): It was observed by customers that these flats are comfortable and lightweight, making them perfect for desk work.
Color Satisfaction (11%): Customers expressed satisfaction with the color, as it was described as great, fabulous, and lovely.

Review topics: ["size","fit","length","issues","color","fabric","weight","legs","material","look","stretch","addition","style","feel","design","pair","lining","quality","shape","shoes","comfort","cut","customer service","mary janes","strap","width","shade","feet","pattern","snug"].

Review highlights

"Love the fit, the color and the whole look." — Sara H.
"The style is fresher and with the broader toe box and stretchy strap these are so comfortable and easy to wear." — Meredith M.
"Perfect fit, perfect color, perfect sizing." — Elizabeth W.

Reviews

Skinny but I love them anyway

"These are so adorable and so easy to slip on and off. I love the stretchy strap and the soft lining on the heel so that you don't get blisters. My only qualms: they are a bit narrow, and the sole is a little slippery."

— Sydney S. (4/5)

So light and comfortable

"I almost returned as they were slippy at first, but as soon as the fluffy layer wore off, they are a good grip for day to day life. I wear them to the office. I love how comfortable they are. I am a UK7 and bought a US10 which fit perfectly. I love them. They feel good quality."

— Jane B. (5/5)

Really really like them!

"I wish the toe box was just a little wider. After a long day and my feet are swollen, my toes feel pinched. That's my only issue, right size, and very cute."

— Amanda H. (4/5)

The Square Mary Jane

"I purchased these shoes on sale nonreturnable in a 7. 5. Love the style and color, however, I had purchased Rothy's in a similar style earlier this year in the same size which fit. I had tried a 7 in my earlier purchase and returned for a 7. 5 thinking that would work on this particular purchase as well. The Square Mary Jane shoe is way to big. Now I'm stuck with a shoe that I would love to wear but it's too big and I can't return for a smaller size."

— Donna B. (3/5)

First pair of mary janes

"I now own 8 pairs of Rothy's from almond loafer to point II to clogs but this is my first pair of mary janes. I took a chance and ordered my normal size 8m but had to exchange for 8. 5m because I am sometimes in between. They are very comfortable as are all of my other styles. I think this style might run a little small based on the almond loafer which I own more of than anything."

— Deborah B. (5/5)

Comfy

"Wore them while my other Rothys were in the wash and found them perfectly comfortable, even though I'm old and have lost some padding on the bottoms of my feet."

— NANCY C. (5/5)

The Square Mary Jane - Pecan Mesh

"LOVE these! Runs a little big but the strap helps. I'm a size 9 but always go a half a size up as I feel it prevents blisters. These are so much fun to wear!"

— Anabella R. (5/5)

Beautiful

"Rothy’s does it again. I have not disliked a single pair and these are no exception. The color is beautiful and the fit is perfect as always!!!"

— Molly F. (5/5)

Cute Shoe

"Shoes are cute, not quite as comfortable as I would have liked. The black is very black."

— Johnna B. (4/5)

Great and stylish

"Beautiful girly shoes which I needed to wear with summer dresses. Sizing it totally off but shoes are pretty. Small blister at first but all good. Never had blisters before but these are worth it and it was almost 100 degrees 🤭"

— Gaja B. (5/5)