The Square Mary Jane

$159
$159
3632 reviews
The Square Mary Jane in Cream Captoe shown from the top.
hover | Model wearing The Square Mary Jane in Cream Captoe.
Alternate view of a model wearing The Square Mary Jane in Cream Captoe.
Close up of the heel of The Square Mary Jane in Cream Captoe, with Rothy's signature blue halo.
The Square Mary Jane in Cream Captoe shown from the side.
The sole of The Square Mary Jane in Cream Captoe shown in diagonal view.
Top view of the square toe and rounded vamp of The Square Mary Jane in Cream Captoe.
Color
Black
Lollipop Red
Wren
Cream Captoe
Classic Cheetah
Size
5
5.5
6
6.5
7
7.5
8
8.5
9
9.5
10
10.5
11
11.5
12
12.5
13
Fits true to size.
Select a size
Find in-store
Select a size to see availability near you.

Free shipping on all orders.
30 days to return or exchange. Learn more.

The Square Mary Jane

Size Chart

Fits true to size. The Square Mary Jane also features a slim, flexible strap that’s easy to slip on—while keeping your foot secure. Learn More

Still not sure what your size is?
Let's Chat
An icon depicting a shoe in a vessel of water.
MACHINE WASHABLE

Toss in the wash with cold water. Air dry. Boom.

An icon depicting a feather drifting above a pile of pillows.
PILLOW-LIKE COMFORT

Features a soft, plush footbed for easy-to-wear comfort.

An icon depicting a plastic bottle.
RECYCLED PLASTIC BOTTLES

It took about 9 plastic bottles to knit these shoes. See how we calculate it.

Model walking in The Square Mary Jane in Wren and showing different angles of the shoes.

Details

The Square Mary Jane in Cream Captoe


  • Soft, flexible upper in ivory with a black captoe.
  • Features a slim, flexible strap that keeps your feet secure.
  • Comfortable insoles in ivory and durable black outsoles.

SKU 075_027_CRMCT

Washing Instructions

  • All of our styles are machine washable—so they last for the long haul. Learn more.
  • Slip out insoles. Toss insoles and shoes in the wash with cold water. 
  • Air dry. No heat, please.
  • Wear again and again.

Sustainability

  • Knit from Rothy’s signature thread, which is spun from plastic bottles. Learn more.
  • It took about 9 plastic bottles to knit this pair of shoes.
Close up of the toe and vamp of The Square Mary Jane, shown from the top. A swatch of red rPET knit. A close up view of the heel and stretchy straps of The Square Mary Jane.
THE SQUARE MARY JANE
  • Forever favorite. Timeless and trendy?! Oh yes, especially with a unique rounded-square toe.
  • Feels incredible. Super soft, lightweight knit construction adds extra comfort to every step. Ahh.
  • Easy to wear. Stretchy straps are extra comfy—and give your look a lil’ something extra.

Overall rating: 4.4118943 / 5 from 3632 reviews.

AI Generated Review Summary

The Square Mary Jane in Cream Captoe offers a soft, flexible upper with a slim, adjustable strap for secure fit. Customers praise its perfect fit, great style, and stunning color. While opinions vary on the toe and strap adjustability, the overall comfort and chic look make it a popular choice.

Summary topics

  • Fit (14%): Customers loved the perfect fit of the product, which was mentioned multiple times in the reviews.
  • Style (8%): Customers expressed satisfaction with the great style of the product, which was mentioned multiple times in the reviews.
  • Color (11%): Customers keep praising the color, with many describing it as great, fabulous, and stunning.
  • Flats Comfort (5%): It was noted by customers that these flats are comfortable and lightweight, making them the best flats ever.
  • Sizing (11%): In general, customers recommend sizing up 1/2 size, but some suggest sizing up half a size.

Review topics: ["size","fit","length","issues","strap","color","fabric","addition","weight","quality","material","shipping","look","feel","shape","service","lining","stretch","comfort","move","weather","design","customer service","piece","pattern","style","width","price","snug","shade"].

Review highlights

  • "Perfect fit, perfect color, perfect sizing." — Elizabeth W.
  • "Love the fit, the color and the whole look." — Sara K.
  • "The fit is perfect, the style is comfy and the color is amazing!!!!" — Cristy H.

Reviews

Beautiful

"Rothy’s does it again. I have not disliked a single pair and these are no exception. The color is beautiful and the fit is perfect as always!!!"

— Molly F. (5/5)

Great and stylish

"Beautiful girly shoes which I needed to wear with summer dresses. Sizing it totally off but shoes are pretty. Small blister at first but all good. Never had blisters before but these are worth it and it was almost 100 degrees 🤭"

— Gaja B. (5/5)

cream captoes

"While I have wanted these for a long time and appreciate that they are washable. After wearing them, I found that I need more cushion underfoot to better support walking and standing for long periods. Additionally, the material does not feel as breathable as I had hoped but because I like the appearance and styles of the shoes, I wish I could consider multiple pairs to switch between."

— Jillian K. (4/5)

So comfy!

"These are my new go to shoe. They are so breathable and comfortable and cute. I love that they go with everything. I should have ordered my exact size because I thought they ran small but they are TTS. I’m going to ask for another pair for Christmas. One bright and one neutral."

— Georgia P. (5/5)

So cute & comfy

"I love them. They liven up any outfit with a bold color. They are super comfortable. I’m usually a 10 wide and I just sized up to 10. 5 for a perfect fit!!"

— Jennifer L. (5/5)

Welcome to my wardrobe!

"Easy, comfy and cute! I got my first pair a few weeks ago. I have already ordered the second pair. No break-in time. Just put the on a go! One of those purchases that worked right away."

— Catherine F. (5/5)

So comfortable!

"This is my first pair and I absolutely love them. They feel great from the get go. I walk over 4 miles a day on them and they are just as comfortable as my tennis shoes."

— Johanna S. (5/5)

I am a shoe junky

"I am a shoe junky and there is not any other brand that compares to Rothy. Shoe comfort is beyond excellent. The style is timeless and the choices are great. The colors of the shoe choices are just beautiful. My shoe cupboard is now dominated by Rothy brand shoes."

— Stephanie K. (5/5)

Beautiful and comfortable for a bunion

"Absolutely love these. I wanted a neutral flat that I could wear with summer dresses. I love the pretty cream color and the black captoe is also fun and functional for my wardrobe because I wear a lot of black. I am a true 9 1/2 and I took my regular size in these. I have a narrow heel and a bunion on one foot. The strap helps keep the shoe in place with the heel consideration, and the way these are shaped the bunion is not super noticeable, which is always a concern with these stretchy shoes. I wore them for a mile walk to a coffee shop the other day and they were comfortable right out of the box."

— Kelsey W. (5/5)

Very comfortable, and cute!

"I’m new to Rothy’s, still trying to grasp the sizing. I’m normally a size 6, that’s what I ordered. They fit, but could go down a half size. It would be helpful if the strap had Velcro to allow adjustment."

— Brenda M. (5/5)

Q&A

Model wearing The Penny Clog in ReVelvet Rodeo Torte.
WOMEN'S SHOES
Shot of both sides of the The Two-Way Tote in Ivy.
BAGS & ACCESSORIES
Two kids wearing The Kids Stretch Sneaker in Firecracker and Bubblegum.
KIDS SHOES
Model wearing The Ravello Penny Loafer in ReVelvet Russet.
MEN'S SHOES