The Square Mary Jane

$100
$100
1851 reviews
Best Seller
The Square Mary Jane in Black shown from the top.
The Square Mary Jane in Black shown from the top.
hover | Model wearing The Square Mary Jane in Black
side | The Square Mary Jane in Black shown from the side.
Top view of the square toe and rounded vamp of The Square Mary Jane in Black.
Close up of the heel of The Square Mary Jane in Black, with Rothy's signature blue halo.
Color
Black
Lollipop Red
Wren
Cream Captoe
Classic Cheetah
Size
5
5.5
6
6.5
7
7.5
8
8.5
9
9.5
10
10.5
11
11.5
12
12.5
13
Fits true to size.
Add to cart
Find in-store

Free shipping on all orders.
30 days to return or exchange. Learn more.
The Square Mary Jane in Black shown from the top.

The Square Mary Jane

(1851)
Size Chart

Fits true to size. The Square Mary Jane also features a slim, flexible strap that’s easy to slip on—while keeping your foot secure. Learn More

Find Your Size

  1. Trace your foot on paper.

  2. Measure from heel to the longest toe.

  3. Use measurement to find your size.

Size Chart
Still not sure what your size is?
Let's Chat
An icon depicting a shoe in a vessel of water.
MACHINE WASHABLE

Toss in the wash with cold water. Air dry. Boom.

An icon depicting a feather drifting above a pile of pillows.
PILLOW-LIKE COMFORT

Features a soft, plush footbed for easy-to-wear comfort.

An icon depicting a plastic bottle.
RECYCLED PLASTIC BOTTLES

It took about 9 plastic bottles to knit these shoes. See how we calculate it.

Model walking in The Square Mary Jane in Wren and showing different angles of the shoes.

Details

The Square Mary Jane in Black


  • Soft, flexible upper in black.
  • Features a slim, flexible strap in black that keeps your feet secure.
  • Comfortable matching insoles and durable tortoise shell outsoles.

SKU 075_011_BLK
Reviews
1851 reviews

Washing Instructions

  • All of our styles are machine washable—so they last for the long haul. Learn more.
  • Slip out insoles. Toss insoles and shoes in the wash with cold water. 
  • Air dry. No heat, please.
  • Wear again and again.

Sustainability

  • Knit from Rothy’s signature thread, which is spun from plastic bottles. Learn more.
  • It took about 9 plastic bottles to knit this pair of shoes.
Close up of the toe and vamp of The Square Mary Jane, shown from the top. A swatch of red rPET knit. A close up view of the heel and stretchy straps of The Square Mary Jane.
THE SQUARE MARY JANE
  • Forever favorite. Timeless and trendy?! Oh yes, especially with a unique rounded-square toe.
  • Feels incredible. Super soft, lightweight knit construction adds extra comfort to every step. Ahh.
  • Easy to wear. Stretchy straps are extra comfy—and give your look a lil’ something extra.

Overall rating: 4.383716 / 5 from 4704 reviews.

AI Generated Review Summary

The Square Mary Jane in Black is praised for its great color, superb look, and perfect fit. Customers appreciate its cute and lightweight design, though opinions on the strap and toe vary. The sizing is inconsistent, with some recommending sizing up.

Summary topics

  • Product Color (11%): Customers keep praising the great color of the product, with multiple reviews expressing love for it.
  • Product Look (9%): Customers appreciated the look of the product, with many describing it as great, superb, and lovely.
  • Flat Design (5%): Customers keep praising the flats, describing them as cute, lightweight, comfy, and great.
  • Mary Jane Design (7%): Customers expressed satisfaction with the Mary Jane, stating it is perfect, amazing, and their new favorite.
  • Product Fit (14%): It was observed by customers that the fit of the product is consistently described as perfect or great.

Review topics: ["size","fit","feel","issues","color","length","look","shipping","quality","fabric","material","pair","stretch","style","weight","shoes","comfort","design","strap","mary janes","shade","width","customer service","flats","shape","comfy","snug","blisters","padding","detail"].

Review highlights

  • "The style is fresher and with the broader toe box and stretchy strap these are so comfortable and easy to wear." — Mmmm9
  • "Perfect fit, perfect color, perfect sizing." — Elizabeth W.
  • "Love the fit, the color and the whole look." — Sara K.

Reviews

Perfect!

"I accidentally got the wrong size. I was able to return those, order the right size, no problems at all. I love these shoes. They fit true to size and washable flats are just amazing!"

— Victoria C. (5/5)

Favorite Rothy’s Style

"This summer I wore this style in multiple colors every time I went somewhere that wasn’t the gym. They are easier to walk in than flip fops and also more protective. The more I wore them, the more I realized how much better they look with the summer outfits I’m throwing together than flip flops. Can’t wash flip flops either."

— Sandra V. (5/5)

Slippery sole

"Shoes are nice but soles are hard and way too slippery. I can actually slide across our wood floors. It would be easy to slip and fall with these shoes on hard surfaces. Quite disappointing as I have a number of Rothy’s which are fine. Makes me wonder about future purchases."

— Kenneth W. (2/5)

Love them!

"It took 2-3 wears for them to get comfortable but now I absolutely love them! A good friend told me to size up and she was right. They feel a bit loose at first but they seem to mold to your foot after a few wears. Love them!"

— Tracey M. (5/5)

No real support

"I love these shoes. They are adorable and fit well. That said, if you need any arch support you will not find it in these shoes. I bought some orthotics to slip in them and now they are fine."

— Jessica F. (3/5)

Love these!

"They are so fun, cute and comfortable as well! The red is the perfect “pop” for a navy, black, brown, beige or animal print combo! If you’re on the fence, buy them! You won’t be sorry!"

— Mary C. (5/5)

Skinny but I love them anyway

"These are so adorable and so easy to slip on and off. I love the stretchy strap and the soft lining on the heel so that you don't get blisters. My only qualms: they are a bit narrow, and the sole is a little slippery."

— Sydney S. (4/5)

So light and comfortable

"I almost returned as they were slippy at first, but as soon as the fluffy layer wore off, they are a good grip for day to day life. I wear them to the office. I love how comfortable they are. I am a UK7 and bought a US10 which fit perfectly. I love them. They feel good quality."

— Jane B. (5/5)

The square toe box is

"The square toe box is narrow. A larger size would be too big. I have a wide foot."

— Khalilah G. (4/5)

Cut is not right for my foot

"They fit me length wise, maybe a little extra room by my heel and the cross strap. However, the front rubbed on the front/outside of my middle toe. It's like the cut of the shoe is not right for my foot."

— Jonathan S. (3/5)

Q&A
WOMEN'S SHOES
The Kids Mary Jane in ReVelvet Metallic Twinkleberry.
KIDS SHOES
Collection shot of the studded bucket bags.
BAGS & ACCESSORIES
The Men's Driver in Dark Green and Syrah.
MEN'S SHOES