AI Generated Review Summary
Customers praise the Max Square Mary Jane shoes for their comfort, style, and versatility. The wider toe box and square toe are particularly appreciated for wider feet. The fit is generally well-received, though opinions on size vary. The color is noted as beautiful and rich, and the shoes are generally comfortable, though some find them tight. The strap has mixed reviews, with some finding it flimsy and others praising its softness.
Review topics: [color, feel, fit, move, size, look, style, issues, strap, comfort, quality, shoes, fabric, material, pattern, toe, shape, texture, design, mary janes, customer service, width, stretch, feet, fun, padding, comfy, flats, difference, detail].
Reviews
Size up! More velvet colors, please!
"Needed comfy shoes for a work conference and these were perfect! I love the velvet look and the elastic straps are stretchy and comfortable- no rubbing on the top of my foot. I have wide feet and this style is perfect. My true size is 8. I wear and 8.5 in The Driver. Tried these on in the store and ended up getting size 9 (no socks). It was a hot day and I’m waiting to see how they fit it cooler months. They were perfect for the week and to wear to work. I’ve gotten many compliments! I haven’t washed these yet, but I love how Rothy’s are machine washable. I hope the velvet comes out with more colors!"
— Jane N. (5/5)
Very pleased with this shoe.
"Very pleased with this shoe. Comfortable and plus looks very fashionable. My only issue was the box it was in, was very damaged when I received it. The shoe was fine, but the box looked like it had gone through a wringer!!!! I did take a picture of the box before I opened it up to make sure that the issue was not damaged. And it was fine. I’m not sure how. The box was also taped, and it was obvious this was done by fedex and not buy you"
— Susan H. (5/5)
Adorable but painful
"Unfortunately, after exchanging for a half size larger, these shoes still are not comfortable. I don't have wide feet so not sure why, but I get a sharp pain up my big toe. I have similar flats from other brands that are much less expensive and feel like being barefoot, so it stinks that my first pair of Rothy's, while soooo cute, don't work for me. The look, color, and material of the shoes are very nice though."
— Zoe S. (2/5)
Love Rothy’s
"This square toe in the brown color works so well with my wardrobe. I love Rothy’s. Lightweight shoe that is easy care, easy travel. Most shoes I wear 10 and in Rothy’s I have ordered 10.5."
— Dorene A. (5/5)
So cute
"Love the look of these shoes, but I have wide feet and these shoes are not as comfortable for me as the round toe Mary Jane. For me, the toe box is a touch too narrow. Likewise the strap would be perfect if a little wider/softer."
— Venkatesh K. (4/5)
Great Shoe
"I really love the color and style. The only downside is the InLove insole. It makes the shoe a little wider at the instep area, which affects the overall fit. I have the double strap Mary Jane’s, which does not have this wider insole, and the fit is perfect."
— Carole M. (3/5)
Love them!
"I love everything about this shoe. The color and beautiful texture is great. They feel like slippers on I've worn them a lot. Lots of room for my toes. I loved getting them on sale as well."
— Tina R. (5/5)
Love these shoes!
"It’s been a long time since I was able to comfortably wear a pair of shoes without socks! These are great, have already recommended the brand to friends. Sized up 1/2 size as recommended, and glad I did. They fit great. My first pair of Rothy’s but definitely not my last!"
— Tara S. (5/5)
Loving them!
"I am a The Point girl, but I loved the texture and color of these Max Square flat. They did not disappoint. They are extremely comfortable to wear while at work. I took a mile walk in them yesterday and they did not rub or feel irritating. I got my typical Rothy’s size (10. 5), which is a half size up from my typical size or a 10."
— Bethany V. (5/5)
Just a little narrow
"The would be perfect is the toebox is a little wider. They are fine, I'm comfortable in them but not for long hours of wear. They look pretty and but need to have back up shor to change into for a full day's wear."
— Ying P. (4/5)
