The Max Square Mary Jane

$159
$159
1414 reviews
Best Seller
The Max Square Mary Jane in Black shown from the top.
hover | Model wearing The Max Square Mary Jane in Black.
Alternate view of a model wearing The Max Square Mary Jane in Black.
The Max Square Mary Jane in Black shown from the side.
The sole of The Max Square Mary Jane in Black shown in diagonal view.
Close up of the heel of The Max Square Mary Jane in Black, with Rothy's signature blue halo.
Top view of the square toe and rounded vamp of The Max Square Mary Jane in Black.
Color
Black
Black Sand
Chocolate
Night Song
Red Crisp Basketweave
Wren
Cream Raffia-Knit
Red Hot
Wheat Raffia-Knit
Cinnamon Crochet
Powder Blue Crochet
Sandy Crochet
Size
5
5.5
6
6.5
7
7.5
8
8.5
9
9.5
10
10.5
11
11.5
12
12.5
13
Fits true to size.
Select a size
Find in-store
Select a size to see availability near you.

Free shipping on all orders.
30 days to return or exchange. Learn more.

The Max Square Mary Jane

Size Chart

The Max Square Mary Jane fits true to size. Learn More

Still not sure what your size is?
Let's Chat
An icon depicting a shoe in a vessel of water.
MACHINE WASHABLE

Toss in the wash with cold water. Air dry. Boom.

An icon depicting a foot stepping on top of a heart.
IN LOVE INSOLE® COMFORT

Features our innovative insole for unbelievable, cushion-like comfort.

An icon depicting a plastic bottle.
RECYCLED PLASTIC BOTTLES

It took about 10 plastic bottles to knit these shoes. See how we calculate it.

Model moving around in The Max Square Mary Jane in Black, showing different angles of the shoe.

Details

The Max Square Mary Jane in Black


  • Soft, flexible upper in black.
  • Comfortable, flexible strap in black keeps your feet secure.
  • Features our In Love Insole® in black for heel-to-toe cushioning and all-day wearability.
  • Black sculpted outsoles provide added comfort and stability.

SKU 232_001_BLK

Washing Instructions

  • All of our styles are machine washable—so they last for the long haul. Learn more.
  • Slip out insoles. Toss insoles and shoes in the wash with cold water. 
  • Air dry. No heat, please.
  • Wear again and again.

Sustainability

  • Knit from Rothy’s signature thread, which is spun from plastic bottles. Learn more.
  • It took about 10 plastic bottles to knit this pair of shoes.
THE MAX SQUARE MARY JANE
  • Square to the max. Sharper toe shape for the ultimate square style.
  • Luxe comfort. Features our In Love Insole®️ for irresistible, all-day comfort.
  • Easy to wear. Stretchy straps are super comfy— and give your look a lil' something extra.

Overall rating: 4.333569 / 5 from 1415 reviews.

AI Generated Review Summary

The Max Square Mary Jane in Black offers a soft, flexible upper and a comfortable, secure strap. Customers appreciate its heel-to-toe cushioning and all-day wearability. The style is versatile and cute, though some have noted issues with sizing and toe box tightness.

Summary topics

  • Comfort: 6%
  • Sizing: 10%
  • Fit: 11%
  • Style: 6%
  • Color: 6%

Review topics: ["size","fit","color","support","look","strap","quality","issues","material","fabric","design","price","comfort","feel","pattern","jeans","style","shape","customer service","shoes","texture","width","fun","toe","difference","shade","comfy","mary janes","snug","lining"].

Review highlights

  • "great fit and comfort as always, and this style and color combo are unique and sophisticated." — Jessica A.
  • "Love the color…style and fit are great." — Lessie P.
  • "Love the pattern, fit, color, and so comfortable." — Gay L.

Reviews

love these!

"stylish, polished, go with everything. the strap could be slightly more sturdy. the square toe is so cute and perfect, but because of the shape, the top of the shoe pushes a little bit on my big toenail. nothing major and they’re otherwise very comfortable but I’m not sure I would wear them for walking all day before experimenting with the length of time and activity level first"

— Kaila G. (4/5)

Almost perfect

"I have wanted a pair of Rothy's for awhile now and finally pulled the trigger. I have narrow feet with high arches. First off, these are super duper cute and I get a lot of compliments. The reviews said they ran true to size so I got my regular 9. 5. To me, they run a bit small, at least in the toe box. My big toes feel pressed down upon when wearing them. Then, my high arches are just angry at me so I have had to try out a few different inserts to help with that. I think I have solved the problem but I wish I had gotten a 10 because maybe that would've made it a little more comfy. There was no break in period, they felt good right out of the box, smallest in the toe box not withstanding."

— Danielle H. (4/5)

Great Travel Shoe

"Comfortable, they hardly take up any room in suitcase, and they go with almost every outfit. I wore them with blouse and nice slacks to a party, with faded jeans and black jeans, and with soft Vuori barrel pants and bright coral sweatshirt. So many options. Enjoy!"

— Denise (5/5)

Beauty hurts

"As cute as they are, I can’t stand to wear them for more than 2-3 hours before my feet start hurting. I tried them on and walked around in them in-store to check the fit before purchasing, and I didn’t have any immediate issues then but with longer term wear — even at a desk job — these get uncomfortable fast. My guess is maybe it’s a shoe width thing? I hope they’ll release a wide foot option, too, in the future. I’d like to try those."

— Ashlynn A. (2/5)

These Mary Jane’s are super

"These Mary Jane’s are super comfortable. The in-store sales person did me right when she recommended I buy a half- size larger than normal and mentioned these had more cushion in the sole than other styles."

— Robin B. (5/5)

Perfect Mary Janes

"I have been looking for a black flat that was stylish but also supportive, and these are just the ticket. The strap is flexible, so while they help keep the shoes from slipping, they don’t cut into your foot. The square toe gives them a sleeker look while not making your foot look too long. I have high arches, so the fact that I can wear them all day and walk with no issues is a HUGE plus."

— Kathryn J. (5/5)

I probably could have gone

"I probably could have gone 1/2 size smaller but didn’t want to chance having the wrong fit on such short notice. The shoes are beautiful and very comfortable. They’re close to my skin tone and blend well with whatever I’m wearing."

— Alexandra R. (5/5)

Cute and comfortable

"These flats are incredibly comfortable. Love the style. My only issue is how loose the strap across the top is. The material they're feels very flimsy."

— Kimberly O. (4/5)

I'm a certified hater

"and I love these shoes! I was prepared to find them overhyped, and in a devastating blow to my Virgo heart, I was wrong. I have had them for about a month now. They are super comfortable and perfect for office days, dinner, or a quick errand. I need a lot of support in shoes, so I typically avoid shoes as flexible as these. I would not recommend these to people with plantar fasciatus if you are going to be on your feet a lot. But for my 9-5, you'll find me reaching for these just about any day. I am typically happiest in a wide fit, but I have had no issues with these. I purchased my typical size."

— Hannah P. (5/5)

I didn't think they'd be this good

"I was skeptical when ads talked about how comfortable they are, but they really do get me through a long day with no pain. The square toe makes me feel chic even if I'm wearing them with basketball shorts. I want moooore."

— Ammie W. (5/5)

Q&A

Woman wearing a blue denim shirt The Espadrille Mary Jane in Black
WOMEN'S SHOES
Woman holding The Cinch Bucket Bag Brown Butter Crochet.
BAGS & ACCESSORIES
The Mini Loafer in Sorbet Stripe shown from the top.
KIDS SHOES
Man wearing The Men's Daily Driver Forest Camo.
MEN'S SHOES