Review topics: [size, fit, strap, support, weight, color, fabric, issues, quality, look, feel, shoes, comfort, style, stretch, mary janes, padding, comfy, band, rothy, feet, pair, cruise, toe, insole, cushion, flats, break, walk, footbed].
Reviews
My new favorite shoe
"I bought the children’s version of these for my niece and thought they were precious. When on a trip to DC, I wanted to go into the Rothys store to try on some loafers and Mary Jane’s since there’s not a store in Charleston, SC. I had no plans for the cruisers for myself but decided to try them on and holy cow! Love them! I am flat footed and have had two surgeries on my right foot. I typically need a 10 wide in shoes. These are wonderful, spacious, comfy and don’t hurt my feet at all!"
— Amanda C. (5/5)
Cute, comfortable
"Great shoes for urban summer walking. As is often the case with Rothy’s, sizing is unpredictable. I typically wear size 8. These were practically falling off my feet. Exchanged for 7. 5 which are still big but 7 was too snug. Really wish Rothy’s sizing was consistent"
— jeanne b. (5/5)
Cute, good for short walks
"I like these a lot, but they are not as cushy as I expected. I added a heel cushion, which helped during long walks around Paris. The red adds a fun pop of color, and I've received compliments. Note that they are not a great hot weather shoe, as they don't breathe as much as one might expect. I wore thin peds , which helped keep them fresh. I would love it if Rothys would create more breathable footbed!"
— Alexandra J. (3/5)
The shoe I keep reaching for
"The red cruiser Mary Jane is the most adorable comfortable shoe. I can’t stop reaching for them this summer. If you’re hesitating definitely buy it- comfortable from the second I put them on, and I walk a lot. Perfect shade of red, true to size."
— Maria U. (5/5)
Toe Box and Bunions
"As someone who has a bunion on both feet, I was excited for these Mary Jane’s bc of the soft sides. First, they are very comfortable and lasted a day at an amusement park with ease, HOWEVER…the opening above the toes on the front actually cuts across in a way that hits the bunions instead of them being cradled inside the soft material. I understand shows aren’t one size fits all issues, but narrow toe boxes and weird cuts in the fit/style, make them very uncomfortable despite how everything else feels. I might never wear them again and as a teacher I was really looking forward to wearing them in my classroom and interacting with my students. But the way they hurt would ruin my whole day. :("
— Catherine K. (2/5)
So cute and comfy!
"I absolutely love these Mary Jane cruisers. The poppy color is adorable, and the shoes are very comfortable! The first time I wore them, I walked around town for 6 hours. I experienced zero discomfort, rubbing, or soreness. I wear an 11. 5 in drivers but the 11 was perfect for me in the cruisers."
— Laura D. (5/5)
Cute, comfortable and lightweight
"I love these shoes. The quilted footbed is so comfortable and there was no break in time needed. I wish I got a half size smaller, but overall I am loving these shoes."
— Krystie C. (5/5)
Best walking shoe!
"I did lots of walking in these and never had an issue!! Super comfy memory-foam type of insole. I have wider than average feet which is why I went up a full size."
— Priscila P. (5/5)
Returned
"I wear size 7 in the Double Buckle Mary Jane, the Daily Loafer, and the Penny. With the Cruiser Mary Jane, there was not enough room for my big toe and it was quite visible. They were not as comfortable for me as the Double Buckle Mary Jane."
— Sandra A. (3/5)
I’ve been wanting these for
"I’ve been wanting these for nearly a year and finally treated myself. I wish I got them sooner! My feet hurt all the time because I walk so much, but these are SO comfortable. I’m thrilled to own a cute pair of shoes I can wear all day that aren’t sneakers and still have happy feet."
— E F. (5/5)
