Review topics: ["size","fit","length","support","color","fabric","material","issues","design","quality","look","addition","lining","feel","shape","pants","comfort","style","stretch","service","pattern","customer service","width","shoes","texture","difference","coverage","point","fun","detail"].
Reviews
Cute / Not comfortable / A bit tight
"Super cute flats and I love the style! I normally wear a size 6. 5 in flats, but these ran a bit narrow and small, so I’d recommend sizing up half a size. The heel also felt pretty stiff and gave me blisters after wearing them. I noticed others mentioned the same issue, and I think a slightly lower heel counter would make them much more comfortable."
— Nojan S. (4/5)
Comfy and stylish
"Great shoe. Regret not buying sooner. The material is much softer and knit- like than I expected. The “recycled water bottles” always made me cautious but they aren’t hard plastic at all. Perfect with leggings, jeans, dress pants and shorts."
— Emily L. (5/5)
L O V E Rothy's
"Rothy's has nailed comfortable shoes that actually look nice. They are in fact so comfortable, that I have sold about 30 other pairs of other flats that I owned. I also bought 5 other pairs of Rothy's to coordinate with more of my clothing. THAT is how much I love these shoes."
— Katherine R. (5/5)
Hooray for Wide!
"I’ve worn Rothy Points for years but they are so much more comfortable now that there is a wide option! They are a bit looser with the wide version, and have a short break-in period, so I had a little trouble with the high backs causing irritation. However, an easy fix was to use Dr. Scholl’s Heel Liner Cusions."
— Mandy F. (4/5)
Not comfortable
"I bought these shoes while I was in New York because Rothy's isn't available in my country. I thought they would be soft and comfortable, but unfortunately they've given me terrible blisters and I simply can't wear them. It's very disappointing, especially considering they cost $150."
— Masha B. (2/5)
Runs very small
"The show runs small, I usually wear a 7 in everything and didn’t realize until I had these on and removing the tags that my toes are totally scrunched in these, very uncomfortable in my typical size and may need up to a full size bigger to fit appropriately. Too late to return now."
— Amber J. (3/5)
Simply comfortable elegance
"I am very tall and hate towering over my date. I love that these shoes look dressy without the heels and can dance the night away without pain for once. Throw them in the washing washing and they look brand new."
— Shavon M. (5/5)
Sizing issue
"I wear size 9M. Based on the website “ fit true to size”, I purchased size 9. When I tried them on, toe boxes ( because of pointy design) were tight. I bought them during 30% sales, not realizing it’s final sales. Now I am stuck with them and unable to exchange. I owned the original Point in 2023. At the time, the website instructed to buy half size up , so I did. It fitted perfectly. I thought the updated Point with cushion has a new design so I did not question the sizing information on the website. I will then know twice about buying shoes from Rothy’s."
— Sherry Y. (3/5)
Good quality but uncomfortable
"Was very excited to try my first pair of Rothy's. I needed a good pair of shoes for my daily walk to work in nyc. Unfortunately, I find that the stretch fabric pulls on my big toes making the nail feel like it's digging in. Therefore, I will not longer be wearing them."
— Samantha H. (1/5)
The point is too pointed for my foot
"I was looking forward to receiving these to use as a dressy flat. I have already purchased 3 pairs of the rounded toe & am thrilled with them. However, the pointed toe makes my foot look really fat and the shoe hurts my outside toe. I must return them but I will exchange them for another pair of rounded toes!"
— Bonny S. (3/5)