The Mary Jane Heel

Regular price NZD $345
Regular price
NZD
Sale price
NZD $345
(includes duties & taxes)
Color
Black
Wine Red
Size
5
5.5
6
6.5
7
7.5
8
8.5
9
9.5
10
10.5
11
11.5
12
12.5
13
Fits true to size.
Select a size

Free shipping on orders above NZD $350.

30 days to return. Learn more.

The Mary Jane Heel

Size Chart

The Mary Jane Heel features a smooth shape, a rounded toebox and a slim, adjustable buckle. This style fits true to size. For a roomier fit or for those with wider feet, we suggest going half a size up. Learn More

An icon depicting a shoe in a vessel of water.
MACHINE WASHABLE

Toss in the wash with cold water. Air dry. Boom.

An icon depicting a foot stepping on top of a heart.
IN LOVE INSOLE® COMFORT

Features our innovative insole for unbelievable, cushion-like comfort.

An icon depicting a feather drifting above a pile of pillows.
PILLOW-LIKE COMFORT

Features a soft, plush footbed for easy-to-wear comfort.

Model walking in The Mary Jane Heel in Black and showing different angles of the shoes.

Details

The Mary Jane Heel in Black


  • Premium knit upper in black with a smooth shape and rounded toebox.
  • Features our In Love Insole® in beige for heel-to-toe cushioning and all-day wearability.
  • Features a slim, flexible strap with an adjustable signature buckle. Set it and forget it.
  • 2-in (5.1-cm) knit-wrapped block heel for added height.
  • Rubber outsole for added traction with every step.

SKU 223_001_BLK

Washing Instructions

  • All of our styles are machine washable—so they last for the long haul. Learn more.
  • Slip out insoles. Toss insoles and shoes in the wash with cold water. 
  • Air dry. No heat, please.
  • Wear again and again.

Sustainability

  • Knit from Rothy’s signature thread, which is spun from plastic bottles. Learn more.
  • It took about 13 plastic bottles to knit this pair of shoes.
The Mary Jane Heel in multiple colors stacked on top of one another. A model wearing The Mary Jane Heel in Wine Red. Closeup of the toe of The Mary Jane Heel. Closeup of the strap and buckle of The Mary Jane Heel.
THE MARY JANE HEEL
  • A little lift. Easy-to-wear 2” block heel adds just the right amount of height.
  • Buckle up. Stretchy, adjustable strap with a signature buckle for a modern MJ style.
  • Always in style. Classic and chic with a timeless rounded toe shape.
  • Luxe comfort. Features our In Love Insole® for irresistible, all-day comfort.

Overall rating: 3.761566 / 5 from 281 reviews.

AI Generated Review Summary

The Mary Jane Heel in Black is praised for its sophisticated and clean look, comfortable heel height, and elegant design. While some customers find the toe box tight, others appreciate its versatility. The fit is generally well-received, though sizing can vary. The color is described as beautiful and eye-catching.

Summary topics

  • Aesthetic Appeal: 11%
  • Heel Height Comfort: 5%
  • Mary Jane Design: 5%
  • Overall Fit: 6%
  • Color Appeal: 5%

Review topics: ["size","fit","strap","support","color","look","design","price","material","comfort","style","issues","shape","feel","customer service","shoes","height","width","comfy","heel","toe","blisters","mary janes","flats","rothy","feet","rothy\u2019s","pair","soles","cushion"].

Review highlights

  • "Beautifully made and fit perfectly without changing my actual size."Jenifer A.
  • "Wife loved the look and style."Anthony D.
  • "Super comfortable and just the right height heel!"Missy S.

Reviews

Incredibly comfortable heel! All-day comfort.

"Incredibly comfortable heel! All-day comfort."

Monika H. (5/5)

Wanted to love them, but just ok

"While I love regular Rothy flats, these are just ok."

Amy B. (3/5)

Elegant but Comfy

"Love this style as it is comfortable and does not put pressure on my bunions. Great with jeans or a dress. This is my second pair"

Constance I. (5/5)

So uncomfortable!

"Love my other Rothy’s but these are terrible. Only wore them for a couple of hours and my feet were shredded after, caused so many blisters."

Kayla S. (1/5)

Excellent shoes, fantastic customer service!

"I have four pairs of Rothy’s and I love them all!! So comfortable and versatile! The company also has outstanding customer service. Shipping is fast and they are quick and great with exchanges!"

Jill B. (5/5)

Too big for me

"Too big for me"

Sarah P. (3/5)

Really Great Heel

"I love the height of this heel, it is so easy to wear, definitely feels like it runs really big in the beginning but once it forms to the foot, it's a perfect fit."

Ash H. (4/5)

Who is the most comfortable

"Who is the most comfortable shoes ever? This One."

Michel T. (5/5)

A Must Buy!

"I am a loyal Rothy’s customer for my work shoes. I’ve been dying to buy the heels for months but was trying to wait for a sale. I am so glad I finally purchased these. They are super comfortable and look lovely in the office! I’m already wanting to buy another color for full price. I ordered the same size I usually wear in the pointed flats and they fit perfect."

Katie L. (5/5)

So comfortable

"These shoes are so nice, can wear for all occasions and feel great wearing them with all styles of clothing!!!"

Gloria G. (5/5)

Q&A

Woman wearing a blue denim shirt The Espadrille Mary Jane in Black
Woman holding The Cinch Bucket Bag	Brown Butter Crochet.
The Mini Loafer in Sorbet Stripe shown from the top.
Man wearing The Men's Daily Driver	Forest Camo.