Review topics: ["size","fit","color","support","design","fabric","material","issues","weight","lining","feel","price","quality","look","style","pants","comfort","weather","shape","addition","texture","padding","snug","wear","pattern","service","shoes","loafers","loafer","pair"].
Reviews
Nice
"Not the most comfortable Rothy’s I own. Very nice looking shoe. I do look forward to kicking them off after a long day though. I own about 8 pairs and this is the 1st pair that I feel this way about. Unsure where they went wrong comfort wise."
— Kelly N. (4/5)
Size inaccuracies
"I own other Rothys but knowing their sizing can vary, I specifically made time to visit a store to try out the model and confirm the size. However the store did not have the color I wanted, so I placed an order online. However, the fit is not the same. It is quiet disappointing because I got it on sale and the shoe is not returnable."
— Monisha S. (1/5)
Don't follow the reviews--order your normal size!
"I spent WAY too much time reading the reviews and studying the size chart, which most recommended going at least a half size up due to the style. I did that, and very much regret it--way too big. Not a huge deal if I could exchange, but these were "final sale" and now I have loose, sloppy shoes that I won't wear. Grrrr. . . ."
— Carolyn T. (2/5)
Cheap and uncomfortable
"The shoe construction feels cheap- the soles are plastic and insubstantial, and the cut of the loafer means the back digs into your heel and the top rubs against your foot bone. These are expensive and they probably cost nothing to make, just feels like a rip-off. Wish I had spent the money on a nice pair of leather loafers instead."
— Charlotte H. (1/5)
These run small, so disappointed
"I normally wear a 6-1/2 ao that’s what I ordered. Within a half hour of wearing them for the first time, I had to take them off because they were so tight and were killing my heels with blisters already. I’ve also found out that they don’t stretch at all. I’m even more upset because I can’t return them or exchange them, and they are expensive shoes."
— Tammie G. (2/5)
Sooo cute and comfy!
"I purchased 2 pair of the Rothy Penny Loafers in Blue Raffia (Knit) and Pink. They were both about 40 percent off and I couldn’t decide between these 2 beautiful colors so I treated myself to both. These are my first Rothy’s and I couldn’t be happier! I wore the pink pair on a recent trip to San Francisco. I walked almost 4 miles and never had a pain, pinch, rubbing, gapping, no issues at all. The shoes are stylish, so comfortable, and wearable with so many things. I absolutely love them! I normally wear a 10. 5, or 11. I ordered the 10. 5 and they fit perfectly!"
— Kelli M. (5/5)
Love these shoes
"I love these shoes, they look and feel great in fact exceeded my expectations on both counts. They are my current go to look."
— Cynthia M. (5/5)
Comfy and Casual
"These loafers are very comfortable! Wore them to work without issue straight out of the box. I found them to be most comfy with thin sock liners. I usually wear a 7 but sized up to a 7. 5 and they fit great."
— Erika V. (5/5)
nice quality and comfortable
"I like them. High quality and comfortable. I haven't worn them enough to fully break them in, but even without being broken in, they're still comfortable. Not stiff at all. I typically wear size 7, but sometimes 7. 5 with shoes that run really narrow. I got size 7 and am glad I did. I like my shoes to fit my feet pretty snug, and I don't think a 7. 5 would've fit as well. I know some people say they run small, but that wasn't my experience, and my feet are wide and often swell throughout the day."
— Aliya T. (5/5)
SUPER COMFY
"This loafer is very comfortable. Much softer than I expected. I am size 7. 5 wide and it is perfect fit but this one I purchased size 8 since I like loose fit. Great for work and travel."
— Yuko W. (5/5)