Review topics: [size, fit, color, issues, feel, look, material, pants, quality, weight, comfort, pair, style, customer service, padding, shoes, shade, pattern, fun, drivers, rothy, support, insole, loafers, wear, feet, toe, loafer, break, blisters].
Reviews
Fabulous feel!!
"Some years back I had decided Rothy's weren't for me...no support. But going into a store to buy for my daughter, I discovered these loafers and was pleasantly surprised to find they had some arch help and nice padding. Wore them straight from the box...no break in and I love them!"
— Marian H. (5/5)
My favorite everyday shoe
"I am so glad you changed the old insole and replaced it with a more supportive one! It is so comfortable. I have a lot of Rothy’s shoes and I like the daily driver the best because it has the most support. I’m always looking for a shoe that is more polished than a sneaker but allows me to do a fair amount of walking and this does the job."
— Susan H. (5/5)
Basic flat shoe
"The shoes are fine for flats. I was expecting them to be more comfortable for the price. I work in sales and I’m on my feet all day. I normally wear Sperry’s and decided to finally give Rothy’s a try. They are not uncomfortable, but for the price I was hoping for more. The color is also not quite as expected."
— Jenine S. (3/5)
Shoes great, shipping is not
"Love my new shoes, they are very cute and comfortable. My biggest complaint is they use the US Postal Service to deliver these. I ordered them on a Sunday. They were supposed to come the following Friday, which was perfect because I bought them for an out-of-state work conference, the delivery got moved to Saturday and then it got moved to Monday when I was leaving. I was gone all week and they ended up being delivered on Thursday after I got back. The only reason I ordered them is because the store did not have my size available. So great shoes but if you’re needing them quick shipping is not accurate."
— Jennifer S. (4/5)
Comfort and Style
"I’ve been wearing good athletic shoes at work primarily for years, and needed a change. The big department store recommended Rothy’s, so I went for it, and I LOVE them! Plenty of room in the toe box, no bunion chafing, not even a break-in period. These just fit right from the start. I have 5 pair so far"
— Virginia C. (5/5)
Best Toe Box So Far
"These are the least restrictive Rothys I've tried and they are very comfortable! I don't have wide feet but am more and more aware of the spacing our feet should ideally have (vs being squished into a triangle). Loved these and ended up ordered a second color. They're great travel shoes! Ah, and with all my Rothys, I sized up (non-Rothys size 8.5-9; drivers size 9.5)."
— Jessica A. (5/5)
Love the upgraded driver
"I have a pair of Rothy Drivers that have the original footbed. I hesitated ordering these (even through they were adorable) because I have heal pain from la k or support in my original pair. I gave them a try knowing they’d been updated and I couldn’t be happier! Already looking at another pair because they are SO comfortable!"
— Courtney Z. (5/5)
Worse than they used to be
"Bought a pair of these three years ago and they fit perfectly. They’re starting to get holes in the heels, which doesn’t bother me too much - I’ve worn them a ton. Ordered a new pair in the same size, and it’s like a totally different, much worse shoe. The new sizing is awful - the shoes are the same length but much larger top to bottom so there’s way too much room and they slip off my feet. Will have to return."
— Shelby E. (1/5)
We visited the Rothy's store
"We visited the Rothy's store at Tysons Corner, but the sales representative was quite unfriendly. As a result, I only bought one pair of shoes. Afterward, I went to Nordstrom, where I received much better customer service and found better prices, so I ended up buying two more pairs there the same day. Because of my experience at the Rothy's store, I do not plan on returning to Rothy’s store. We visited the Rothy's store at Tysons Corner, but the sales representative was quite unfriendly. As a result, I only bought one pair of shoes. Afterward, I went to Nordstrom, where I received much better customer service and found better prices, so I ended up buying two more pairs there the same day. Because of my experience at the Rothy's store, I do not plan on returning."
— Ornuma L. (4/5)
Comfy Shoe, Noisy Sole
"I've been buying Rothy's Shoes since 2021 and always had a good experience, expect for now. I bought 2 pairs of the Daily Driver shoes, and the soles of both pairs of shoes are extremely noisy when you walk on concrete, tile, hardwood floors - any floor that isn't carpet. I've kept the shoe because I have a hard size foot to fit. I will not be buying this shoe anymore. The shoe is not worth $150 given how noisy the shoe is when you're not walking on carpet."
— Christine R. (3/5)