Review topics: ["size","fit","weight","support","color","fabric","material","issues","design","quality","look","addition","lining","feel","shape","pants","comfort","style","pattern","service","snug","texture","padding","shoes","weather","loafers","loafer","pair","rothy","break"].
Reviews
Sooo cute and comfy!
"I purchased 2 pair of the Rothy Penny Loafers in Blue Raffia (Knit) and Pink. They were both about 40 percent off and I couldn’t decide between these 2 beautiful colors so I treated myself to both. These are my first Rothy’s and I couldn’t be happier! I wore the pink pair on a recent trip to San Francisco. I walked almost 4 miles and never had a pain, pinch, rubbing, gapping, no issues at all. The shoes are stylish, so comfortable, and wearable with so many things. I absolutely love them! I normally wear a 10. 5, or 11. I ordered the 10. 5 and they fit perfectly!"
— Kelli M. (5/5)
nice quality and comfortable
"I like them. High quality and comfortable. I haven't worn them enough to fully break them in, but even without being broken in, they're still comfortable. Not stiff at all. I typically wear size 7, but sometimes 7. 5 with shoes that run really narrow. I got size 7 and am glad I did. I like my shoes to fit my feet pretty snug, and I don't think a 7. 5 would've fit as well. I know some people say they run small, but that wasn't my experience, and my feet are wide and often swell throughout the day."
— Aliya T. (5/5)
Pure comfort
"I don’t like to have to break in shoes and Rothy’s gives that to me. Pure comfort !!! Loved my loafers the moment I tried them on…. I’m in level obsession! Definitely going for another pair."
— Ana S. (5/5)
Excellent style but a bit narrower than expected
"Luckily the material is stretchy so they're not uncomfortable but you can see the shape of my foot above the sole, so not ideal. I love them but def for a narrower foot"
— Lisa L. (4/5)
These are the cutest shoes.
"These are the cutest shoes. I didn’t even need shoes, but these were so cute when I walked by the window I had to go in and look at them - so far so good on the comfort."
— Ellen T. (5/5)
loafer with some arch support
"I have always wanted a pair of Rothy’s pointy but less of arch support and even though i sized up and put more cushion, it just didn’t work for me making a lot of pain with toes and barely support. Finally I went to store. I got recommendation of this Loafer. I need to size up for 7. 5 instead of 7. It has a bit strong bottom than other Rothy’s. The insole arch support is minimal but some support. Somehow back of the shoes heel area is a bit shorter. It didn’t wrap your heel like other loafers. I think the design has flaws. I wore for 3 conference days. It was a bit painful at toes area and heel area by the end of the day compared to my other loafers like Sam Edelman Loraine loafer."
— Zar T. (4/5)
Pretty in Pink
"I love the penny loafers as they provide a bit more support than the driver. The pink is a great neutral year round."
— Amy H. (5/5)
So many compliments
"I get compliments every time I wear these shoes. So glad they made an animal print. They are comfy as all Rothys are. I can wear them and be on my feet all day long! And bonus with this color is that it hides dirt really well. Super interested to try animal print in other Rothy shoes. Like all Rothys, I have to go half a size up from my regular."
— Rachel P. (5/5)
Cute But Not Comfortable
"I originally ordered an 8, but they were too big (literally coming off my foot with each step), so I went to the closest store I could find and tried on a 7. 5 which fit and seemed much more comfortable. They unfortunately didn’t have the color I wanted, so I had to order them. The first day I wore these, things seemed great. I wore them all day and while they aren’t the most supportive shoe, I felt fine. The second day, however, my heels started to get horribly cut up. I put some bandages on and pushed through, hoping they’d break in and it would be fine, but as I continued to wear them the blisters persisted and my feet ached. After a week of wearing these, I can say I’m incredibly disappointed. I was hoping these would be an every day shoe, but the comfort is NOT there. I love that they’re sustainable and washable, but I need them to also be wearable. Would not recommend."
— Philip W. (2/5)
Stylish comfort
"Love the color style and comfort of these great shoes. Wore them with little socks to tighten fit. First few outings the bottom of soles were slippery"
— Patricia M. (5/5)
