AI Generated Review Summary
The Point II Desert Cat shoes offer a premium knit upper with a black and cream leopard print, featuring a smooth, refined shape. Customers praise the comfort and style, with specific mentions of the wider and comfier toe box, perfect fit, and beautiful color. However, some customers reported issues with sizing and occasional discomfort.
Review topics: [size, fit, length, support, color, fabric, material, issues, design, quality, look, addition, lining, feel, shape, pants, comfort, style, stretch, service, pattern, customer service, width, shoes, texture, difference, coverage, point, fun, detail].
Reviews
Cute / Not comfortable / A bit tight
"Super cute flats and I love the style! I normally wear a size 6. 5 in flats, but these ran a bit narrow and small, so I’d recommend sizing up half a size. The heel also felt pretty stiff and gave me blisters after wearing them. I noticed others mentioned the same issue, and I think a slightly lower heel counter would make them much more comfortable."
— Nojan S. (4/5)
Comfy and stylish
"Great shoe. Regret not buying sooner. The material is much softer and knit- like than I expected. The “recycled water bottles” always made me cautious but they aren’t hard plastic at all. Perfect with leggings, jeans, dress pants and shorts."
— Emily L. (5/5)
L O V E Rothy's
"Rothy's has nailed comfortable shoes that actually look nice. They are in fact so comfortable, that I have sold about 30 other pairs of other flats that I owned. I also bought 5 other pairs of Rothy's to coordinate with more of my clothing. THAT is how much I love these shoes."
— Katherine R. (5/5)
Hooray for Wide!
"I’ve worn Rothy Points for years but they are so much more comfortable now that there is a wide option! They are a bit looser with the wide version, and have a short break-in period, so I had a little trouble with the high backs causing irritation. However, an easy fix was to use Dr. Scholl’s Heel Liner Cusions."
— Mandy F. (4/5)
Not comfortable
"I bought these shoes while I was in New York because Rothy's isn't available in my country. I thought they would be soft and comfortable, but unfortunately they've given me terrible blisters and I simply can't wear them. It's very disappointing, especially considering they cost $150."
— Masha B. (2/5)
Runs very small
"The show runs small, I usually wear a 7 in everything and didn’t realize until I had these on and removing the tags that my toes are totally scrunched in these, very uncomfortable in my typical size and may need up to a full size bigger to fit appropriately. Too late to return now."
— Amber J. (3/5)
Simply comfortable elegance
"I am very tall and hate towering over my date. I love that these shoes look dressy without the heels and can dance the night away without pain for once. Throw them in the washing washing and they look brand new."
— Shavon M. (5/5)
Sizing issue
"I wear size 9M. Based on the website “ fit true to size”, I purchased size 9. When I tried them on, toe boxes ( because of pointy design) were tight. I bought them during 30% sales, not realizing it’s final sales. Now I am stuck with them and unable to exchange. I owned the original Point in 2023. At the time, the website instructed to buy half size up , so I did. It fitted perfectly. I thought the updated Point with cushion has a new design so I did not question the sizing information on the website. I will then know twice about buying shoes from Rothy’s."
— Sherry Y. (3/5)
Good quality but uncomfortable
"Was very excited to try my first pair of Rothy's. I needed a good pair of shoes for my daily walk to work in nyc. Unfortunately, I find that the stretch fabric pulls on my big toes making the nail feel like it's digging in. Therefore, I will not longer be wearing them."
— Samantha H. (1/5)
The point is too pointed for my foot
"I was looking forward to receiving these to use as a dressy flat. I have already purchased 3 pairs of the rounded toe & am thrilled with them. However, the pointed toe makes my foot look really fat and the shoe hurts my outside toe. I must return them but I will exchange them for another pair of rounded toes!"
— Bonny S. (3/5)