Review topics: ["size","fit","fabric","support","color","material","style","move","design","feel","look","issues","quality","stretch","comfort","addition","strap","pattern","shape","pants","texture","customer service","width","price","padding","fun","snug","wear","difference","versatility"].
Reviews
Loving them!
"I am a The Point girl, but I loved the texture and color of these Max Square flat. They did not disappoint. They are extremely comfortable to wear while at work. I took a mile walk in them yesterday and they did not rub or feel irritating. I got my typical Rothy’s size (10. 5), which is a half size up from my typical size or a 10."
— Bethany V. (5/5)
Rothy’s are the best!
"Just happened to park right in front of a Rothy’s in Pasadena when I was in SoCal for a girl’s weekend. How could I NOT go in and buy a new pair?!! It would be like breaking some Girl’s Weekend rule. And these beauties do not disappoint! The square toe on these make them extra comfortable and I love that I can wear them with the thin strap on top of or under my foot. 10 out of 10!"
— Shawn E. (5/5)
Run very small
"Even though it says these are true to size, they are not. I’m always an 8. 5 and I got 8. 5 in these. Store associate said that was correct. I wore them for one day and they pushed down so much on my toes. I ended up giving them to my mom and buying a 9 from Poshmark, but that meant I wasted money in the process. They need a better return policy if they’re going to make the sizing insane and dishonest."
— Emily (2/5)
Perfect Summer Shoe
"I never leave reviews, but these shoes are just perfect. I'm a young professional who is entering the business casual world, and I have been struggling to find shoes I can wear all day during the summer. These have been perfect as they are so comfortable and lightweight. I have never had any issues with blisters or uncomfortable rubbing. I genuinely have no complaints and recommend them to everyone."
— Mariana M. (5/5)
The Wheat Raffia knit is tighter. Size Up
"I ordered these in black and they fit phenomenally well. Very comfortable. Ordered my regular size. Definitely a True to Size shoe. I assumed these would too. However the Raffia knit is tighter. I ordered these immediately my big toes were complaining. I can't exchange them for the next size up because these were final sale. Just be warned, if you get the Wheat Raffia knit, order a size up."
— Jennifer W. (3/5)
Love the comfort and the look
"I fell in love with these crocheted Mary Jane’s after I bought a jeans tress with matching crocheted trim. They’re as comfortable as my red slingbacks and I’m assuming they will wash up nicely when needed, just like the others."
— Elizabeth G. (5/5)
Beautiful shoe, not wide-feet friendly
"I purchased The Max Square Mary Jane (Sandy Crochet) for my upcoming vacation. I have slightly wide feet, so I always struggle to find cute flats that fit well, and these seemed promising at first. They felt fine trying them on in the store, but after wearing them for a full day, my toes started feeling quite uncomfortable within about 30 minutes. Unfortunately I won't be able to wear them on my trip. If you have wider feet, I'd recommend trying them on and walking around in them for a while before committing, or possibly sizing up."
— Chiho E. (1/5)
Absolutely Thrilled!
"I’m so thrilled I purchased these shoes! They look fantastic, and I can comfortably wear them all day. I even get compliments from complete strangers. The only thing is that they’re slightly loose—enough to make me consider sizing down, but not quite enough to actually do it. Overall, they’re a great pair of shoes and fantastic for this time of year."
— Elise B. (4/5)
So comfy, just size up!
"Love these!! Bought because of an influencer who said she walked 20k steps in Paris in these, and she is totally right! I had to exchange for a half size up because the toe box is a bit tight with no stretch."
— Brooke A. (5/5)
Cute and comfortable
"These are very comfortable, stylish, and well made. I have several pairs of Rothy's and use them all for work shoes. They absolutely get the job done without out breaking the bank or sacrificing fashion. Highly recommended."
— Shaniece K. (5/5)